Legislation

The Copyright Act's Next Fight Is Over Blanket Fees

Four years after the mechanical licensing overhaul, the argument has moved from who collects the money to how the rate is set.

PoliticsThe Politics DeskBy Marcus Whitfield
The Copyright Act's Next Fight Is Over Blanket Fees
Illustration for the The Politics Desk

The mechanical licensing system built in the last rewrite was designed to solve a simple problem: nobody knew who to pay for a stream. It did not settle the harder question, which is how much the rate should be and who gets to argue about it.

The current dispute is procedural but consequential. Publishers want the settlement process to consider how quickly the market is growing; services want the comparison anchored to older physical-era benchmarks. Both sides have filed the same charts with opposite conclusions.

For songwriters, the practical effect of the proceeding is measured in fractions of a cent per stream. For the services, it is measured in quarterly earnings calls. That asymmetry is why the trade groups spend so much on it, and why almost nobody outside the filings follows it.